46
Chapter 1 / Re: Section 1.4: Question 29 Proof Check
« on: October 08, 2020, 09:27:59 AM »
Indeed
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Hi there, I think there might be some problem with Q28. After I found the integrating factor and then solve for the solution, it's impossible to find the solution of my h(y) in this case (see the last line of my writing).If you found an integrating factor correctly there should be no problem to $h(y)$. There is a problem with your solution, not with the problem.
In the textbook, it is e^(-2y). Maybe this one is correct.Both are correct
is du/dx+i dv/dx? Why can't we take the derivative with respect to y?You can take also derivative by $y$ but you need to multiply it by $i$ (think why)
why the complex plane is both open and closed? why did it close? Because by definition, a set is called closed if it contains its boundary. And I don't see the complex plane contains its boundary.And what is the boundary of $\mathbb{C}$?
In week 3 lecture 3, we get the example $(-y\sin(x)+y^3\cos(x))dx+(3\cos(x)+5y^2\sin(x))dy=0$. We determine that this equation is not exact, but that we can make it exact by multiplying the equation by $y^2$. We then find the general solution to the new equation is $y^3\cos(x)+y^5\sin(x)=C$.We have not modified equation, but simply multiplied it by an integrating factor. These two equations are equivalent, except as $y=0$, that means $C=0$. But $y=0$ os also a solution to the original equation. Checking this would give you a 100% correct solution, otherwise it is almost perfect
My question is why is this good enough? We didn't answer the original question. We answered a modified version which we chose specifically because it seems easier to us. Shouldn't we still find a solution to the original equation $(-y\sin(x)+y^3\cos(x))dx+(3\cos(x)+5y^2\sin(x))dy=0$? Is there some way we can "divide out" $y^2$ from $y^3\cos(x)+y^5\sin(x)=C$ to get it?
I could be wrong, but I think we just try each one until we get one that worksIndeed.