Toronto Math Forum
APM346-2012 => APM346 Math => Term Test 1 => Topic started by: Victor Ivrii on October 16, 2012, 06:30:11 PM
-
The functions $H$ and $Q$ are defined as follows:
\begin{equation*}
H(x) = \left\{\begin{aligned}
&1, \qquad&&x>0,\\
&0, \qquad&&x \leq 0,
\end{aligned}\right.
\end{equation*}
\begin{equation*}
Q(x) = \left\{\begin{aligned}
&1, \qquad&&|x| \leq 1,\\
&0, \qquad&&|x| > 1.
\end{aligned}\right.
\end{equation*}
Consider the function
\begin{equation*}
C(x) = \int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} H(x-y) Q(y) dy.
\end{equation*}
- (a) Graph the function $C(x)$.
- (b) Identify the set of points $x$ where $C(x) >0.$
-
Hopeful solution attached!
-
Solution is attached,
-
We have two rather different answers and the person who posted after should explain what's wrong with the previous posts. This is a general remark without endorsement of any particular solution.
-
Solution is attached,
Aida, I think your solution is not correct - the integral from -1 to 0 will only be 0 if x < y in H(x-y), i.e. x < -1.
Also, consider extreme cases - for C(-100), H(-100-y) can never be greater than 0, so a solution with C(x) = 1 cannot be right (unless I've totally misunderstood something).
-
I solved the question in the same way as Aida Razi did. Of course for part b, C(x) > 0 for all x.
-
I solve the question in the same way as Aida Razi did. Of course for part b, C(x) > 0 for all x.
Yes, as C(x) is a constant function and it is equal to one, then x is lR: it can be any real number.
-
Solution is attached,
Aida, I think your solution is not correct - the integral from -1 to 0 will only be 0 if x < y in H(x-y), i.e. x < -1.
Also, consider extreme cases - for C(-100), H(-100-y) can never be greater than 0, so a solution with C(x) = 1 cannot be right (unless I've totally misunderstood something).
I believe your solution is not correct; H(x) and H(x-y) has the same value for these two different domain because it is a constant function.
-
I agree with Ian's solution. The value of H(x-y) depends on both x and y. So you have to break the scenarios regarding to x when doing the integral.
-
Solution is attached,
Aida, I think your solution is not correct - the integral from -1 to 0 will only be 0 if x < y in H(x-y), i.e. x < -1.
Also, consider extreme cases - for C(-100), H(-100-y) can never be greater than 0, so a solution with C(x) = 1 cannot be right (unless I've totally misunderstood something).
I believe your solution is not correct; H(x) and H(x-y) has the same value for these two different domain because it is a constant function.
Shouldn't they be different though? For H(x), it's 1 for x>0 and 0 for x<=0, but H(x-y) is 1 for x-y>0, or x>y, and 0 for x<=y.
In any case, how can C(-100) be nonzero? x-y=-100-y>0 is impossible for -1<=y<=1, which is the only area where Q(y) is nonzero.
-
We are only asked to draw the graph but not the functional form, don't we?
-
Ian is correct. BTW,
Operation $f*g$, $(f*g)(x)=\int_{-\infty}^\infty f(x-y)g(y)\,dy$ is called a convolution (we implicitly met it and will discuss when study Fourier transform),
$H(x)$ is called Heaviside function and $(H*f)(x)=\int_{-\infty}^x f(y)\,dy$. Therefore the answer is such integral of $Q(x)$ and
\begin{equation*}
(Q*H)(x)=\left\{\begin{aligned}
& 0 \qquad&& x<-1,\\
&x+1 && -1<x<1,\\
&2 && x\ge 1.
\end{aligned}\right.
\end{equation*}
-
Solution is attached,
Aida, I think your solution is not correct - the integral from -1 to 0 will only be 0 if x < y in H(x-y), i.e. x < -1.
Also, consider extreme cases - for C(-100), H(-100-y) can never be greater than 0, so a solution with C(x) = 1 cannot be right (unless I've totally misunderstood something).
I believe your solution is not correct; H(x) and H(x-y) has the same value for these two different domain because it is a constant function.
Shouldn't they be different though? For H(x), it's 1 for x>0 and 0 for x<=0, but H(x-y) is 1 for x-y>0, or x>y, and 0 for x<=y.
In any case, how can C(-100) be nonzero? x-y=-100-y>0 is impossible for -1<=y<=1, which is the only area where Q(y) is nonzero.
Sorry Ian, You are right ???